Ann Althouse has a post about feral cats. She links to a Minnesota Star Tribune article that makes the point that feral cats are fair game in Minnesota. I hadn’t even bothered to check if feral cats were an unprotected species in other states. A few groups in Minnesota oppose the cat hunt, but they offer no real alternative. One group called Camp Companion has captured, sterilized and returned 230 feral cats. Is that really an achievement when the feral cat population is estimated in the millions? It’s been estimated that feral cats kill 1 million birds each day throughout the United States. That is an estimate on the low end. The higher end estimate would be 27 million birds killed each day by feral cats. That doesn’t even count the number of native endangered small mammals killed by cats, or the number of native animals that die due to competition with feral cats.
So why is the feral cat hunt a bad idea? I’ve seen opponents try to argue that people will be accidentally shot by hunters shooting housecats, hunters will be killing cats in the city and family pets will be killed indiscriminately. If those accusations were valid, then there would be some sort of news of that type coming out of Minnesota. Hunters don’t hunt inside the city. There are laws about that and they are followed. If hunters ignored these laws, then you’d have duck hunters setting up blinds at the UW Madison Memorial Union to shoot some ducks. Cat lovers also need to face the fact that if they let their pet outside to roam, then their cat is contributing to the problem. Even if their cat is spayed/neutered, they can still kill native species.
The cat lovers oppose the hunt only because they humanize cats. That’s fine; they don’t have to kill cats. Others will take care of it. Just like others take care of getting meat to the grocery store. It’s not as if the Humane Society does not kill millions of cats each year. Hunters can do the same without taking the cats to the Humane Society which keeps the cat locked up for a few weeks before destroying them, wasting time and resources.